You hear it at night in a Gqeberha home: a cistern that refills itself every twenty minutes, or a constant thin trickle into the pan that you stop noticing after a week. It is one of the cheapest repairs in a house and one of the most ignored, and an ignored one keeps working on your water bill long after you have stopped hearing it.
A running toilet only has four causes, and you can usually work out which one it is in two minutes with the lid off.
How the cistern actually works
Three parts, and every running toilet is one of them failing.
The fill valve lets water in and stops when the float reaches its set height. The flush valve, sometimes a flap and sometimes a drop valve, lifts when you press the button and then closes to seal the outlet. The overflow is the safety: if the fill valve never shuts off, water escapes down the overflow pipe into the pan instead of onto the floor.
Understanding that order matters, because it tells you what a trickle into the pan means. Water entering the pan when nobody has flushed is either a flush valve that is not sealing, or a fill valve that is set so high the cistern runs into the overflow.
The two minute diagnosis
Lift the lid and watch what happens after a flush finishes.
- Water stops, then starts again a few minutes later with no one touching it. The flush valve seal is passing. Water leaks out, the level drops, the fill valve tops it up. That cycle is the noise at night.
- A visible trickle into the pan that never stops. Again the flush valve seal, or a drop valve that is not seating because of grit or scale on the seat.
- Water running into the overflow pipe. The fill valve is not shutting off, or the float has been set too high, or the arm is catching on something inside the cistern.
- The cistern will not fill at all. Not a running toilet but the same parts: a blocked inlet filter or a dead fill valve.
A dye test settles it when you cannot see the trickle. Put a few drops of food colouring in the cistern, leave it twenty minutes without flushing, then look in the pan. Colour in the pan means the seal is passing.
Cause one: the flush valve seal
The cheapest fix in plumbing. A rubber seal that has gone hard, grown a film of scale, or been cut by a piece of grit.
On a flap style valve, the seal is a rubber disc that lifts out. On a drop valve it is a ring around the base. Either way the part costs very little and the job is minutes once the water is off.
If the seat itself is rough or scaled, clean it before fitting the new seal, or the new one will fail the same way within a month.
Cause two: the fill valve
The valve fails to shut off, so the cistern keeps filling and dumps the excess down the overflow. Symptoms are a hiss that never stops and water visibly running into the overflow pipe.
A fill or flush valve replacement with us is R400 to R750, and it is one of the highest value small jobs in a house, because a valve that will not shut off is wasting water continuously.
The cheaper alternative, replacing just the washer inside the valve, works when the valve body is sound. It does not work on the sealed cartridge types that most modern cisterns use, and that is the point where the whole valve gets replaced.
Cause three: float height and obstruction
Before buying anything, look at the float. If the water level is set so high that it sits at the overflow mouth, the cistern will run into the overflow forever, no matter how good the valve is.
Adjusting the height takes a minute. The same minute catches the other version of this fault: a float arm catching on the inlet pipe, a piece of scale, or the edge of the cistern lid.
Most people who buy a valve and find the problem unchanged have skipped this check.
Cause four: the seat and the pan connector
Less common, and it shows differently. If the water on the floor is at the base rather than running into the pan, the fault is the pan connector or the seal between the pan and the floor, not the cistern at all.
That is a different job and a different set of parts, and it is worth checking before assuming a running noise is a cistern problem.
The parts, and how to buy the right one
A cistern has far fewer parts than it looks like it has. Before you buy anything, take a photo of the inside of the cistern with the lid off. The valve type is what decides which seal or cartridge you need, and there are several that look similar from above.
Three things are worth knowing at the shop:
- Flap valves and drop valves use different seals. They are not interchangeable, and a seal that "looks about right" will leak again within a week.
- Sealed cartridge fill valves cannot be repaired, only replaced. If the top of the valve is a sealed unit with no visible washer, stop trying to fix it.
- Buy the same brand as the valve in the cistern if you can. Mixing brands inside one cistern is where alignment problems start.
A photo at the counter saves a second trip, and a second trip is what turns a fifteen minute job into a week of a running toilet.
Turning the water off, and back on
Every cistern has an isolation valve, usually a small screwdriver slot on the supply pipe below the cistern, or a tap on the wall. Turn it clockwise until it stops. If there is no isolator, the house main has to come off, which is worth knowing before you start rather than halfway through.
Flush once after isolating to empty the cistern, then sponge out what is left so the new seal goes onto a clean, dry seat. Fit the part, turn the water back on slowly, let the cistern fill, and watch one full flush before you put the lid back.
If the cistern will not stop filling after that, the fill valve needs setting or replacing, and that is the point to stop rather than to keep adjusting.
What it costs
Published per-job ranges for the work we do:
- Toilet seat replaced: R250 to R500
- Toilet fill or flush valve replaced: R400 to R750
- Silicone redone on a bath or basin: R450 to R800
- A dripping tap washer replaced: R350 to R650
Materials and fittings are quoted separately and approved before anything is bought. A new valve is usually the main cost in the job, and there is no benefit in buying the cheapest one twice.
When it becomes a plumber's job
A cistern is a self-contained unit and most of it is handyman work. What is not:
- Altering or replacing supply pipework inside the wall or under the floor.
- Moving a toilet, which means drainage and a new pan connector position.
- Anything involving the geyser, the main supply or the pressure reducing valve.
- Work that needs a certificate of compliance.
We will tell you when a job crosses that line rather than take it and hope. It is the same boundary that applies to electrical work, and it exists because a botched drain is expensive to fix and a botched cistern is merely annoying.
Why it is worth doing now
A running toilet is a constant, low-level water loss. You will not see it as a spike on a bill the way you would see a burst pipe, which is exactly why it runs for months. What you will see, eventually, is a valve that has been cycling thousands of times and a cistern that needs a full rebuild rather than a seal.
It is a fifteen minute job that most people defer for a year.
Not sure if it is the seal or the overflow? Put a few drops of food colouring in the cistern and leave it twenty minutes without flushing. Colour in the pan means the seal is passing.
Do it with the rest of the list
This is the classic single-item booking that is hard to justify on its own, and the reason to batch it. A running toilet and a dripping tap together are one visit. Add the loose cupboard hinge, the door that sticks and the toilet seat that rocks and you have turned four annoyances into one hour of work.
WhatsApp 067 397 3341 with what the cistern is doing and a photo of the inside of the valve if you can get one. It usually means the right part arrives on the first visit.
Got a list that needs working through?
Send it on WhatsApp with a photo or two and you get a price back, before anything is booked.
Send the list