A door sticks in winter because the timber has taken on moisture and swollen, not because the door has grown. Sanding the edge clears it for this winter, and it also removes the very material that will swell next winter, so the door comes back tighter and starts binding earlier than it did before.
Doors in Gqeberha and Port Elizabeth move with the seasons just like doors anywhere else, and the older the door, the more it moves. If yours is catching at the top, dragging on the floor or rubbing the frame down one side, what you do about it depends on which of three things is actually happening. Two of those three are not the door at all, and they are the two most people miss.
What a wet and dry cycle does to a timber door
Timber takes on moisture out of the air when humidity is high and gives it back when the air dries out, and it moves mostly across its width and thickness rather than along its length. A wet winter here means damp air, houses closed up against the weather and no sun drying anything out, so a door that was comfortable in summer swells just enough to catch on the frame. When spring dries the air, the door shrinks back and the problem appears to fix itself. That is the whole cycle, and it is why a door that stuck last winter is almost certain to stick again this winter. A door that fits perfectly in a dry March can be catching by July with nothing changing except the air, and no door settles down and learns to cope on its own.
Where the door binds, and what that tells you
- Catching at the top corner on the latch side: usually swelling across the width of the door, often with a frame that has shifted slightly as well
- Dragging on the floor: swelling at the bottom edge, or a door that was already sitting close to the floor before it swelled
- Rubbing along one whole side: swelling plus a frame that is slightly out of square, which is common in older houses
- Binding only when it is closed rather than as it swings: the latch or the strike plate rather than the door
- Loose while it swings but tight once shut: a dropped hinge, which imitates a swelling door very convincingly
Why sanding works this year and fails next year
Sanding the edge is the fix most people reach for, and it does work on the day. The binding edge gets taken back, the door swings freely and the job looks finished. The trouble is what has been removed. A door only swells as far as its clearance allows, and sanding lowers the point at which it starts to catch. Next winter the same weather arrives, the door swells the same amount and there is less room than before, so it binds sooner and harder. Sanding again buys another year and makes the year after that worse. There is also a limit to how many times it can be done, and that limit arrives sooner on a hollow core door than on a solid one.
Do that over a few winters and you are left with a door that has visibly lost its edge, a gap that lets in draughts and dust in summer, and a problem that is now partly of your own making. The edge is also the part of a door that shows most once it has been cut back, particularly on a painted door where the cut breaks the line of the face.
The fix that lasts: adjust the hinges and the frame
The better approach is to move the door rather than to reduce it. In most cases a sticking door is being held slightly out of line by its hinges, or by a frame that has moved, and correcting that gives the door the clearance it needs without losing any timber. A hinge can be packed or reset, screws that have lost their grip in the frame can be reworked, a worn hinge can be replaced and a frame that is out of square can be adjusted. It is a slower job than a quick sand, and it holds up far better across the seasons.
There is a real case for planing, and it is the case where the door genuinely is too big for its opening: a replacement door that was never fitted properly, a door that swelled after water got into it, or a floor that has been lifted or levelled since the door went in. Where planing is the answer, the cut edge gets sealed or repainted afterwards, because a bare edge takes on moisture faster than a finished one and starts the whole cycle going again.
Older doors, older suburbs and the coastal difference
Newer doors are usually steadier. Engineered cores and modern finishes cope with moisture better than a solid timber door made decades ago, and the frames they hang in are more often square. Older housing stock is a different matter. Homes around Newton Park, Charlo and Mount Croix mostly date from a time when doors were solid timber and frames were built in place, and a door that has hung in the same frame ever since has had a great many winters to move. When somebody in those suburbs calls about a door that sticks every winter, the answer is usually the door and the frame together rather than one or the other.
Coastal homes have their own version of the problem. Salt air strips the plating off cheap hinges and eats the screws that hold them, so a door near the sea is more likely to drop than to swell, and the fix is a set of hinges that will survive the air rather than an adjustment to the door itself.
What it costs
- Sticking door adjusted: R280 to R500
- Door planed and refitted: R400 to R650
- Hinges replaced: R200 to R380
Door work is quoted as a fixed price per job, and those are the published ranges. The gap between the first two lines is the amount of work rather than a markup, because adjusting hinges is quicker than taking a door off, planing it, refitting it and making good the finish. Hinges and any other fittings are quoted separately and approved before anything is bought. If the job turns out to be a frame problem rather than a door problem, that changes the price, and it gets discussed before work starts rather than added afterwards.
If your door only sticks in the wet months and swings freely again by October, hold off on the sandpaper. A seasonal door is a door that needs its hinges and its frame looked at, and every sanding shortens the time you have to fix it properly.
The short version
A door that sticks in winter has swollen with moisture, so sanding the edge clears it now and brings the problem back sooner next year. Check the hinges and the frame first, because a door that has dropped or a frame that has moved imitates a swelling door almost exactly, and correcting either of those removes no timber at all.
Send a photo of the door and the gap along its top edge on WhatsApp, with a line about what it rubs against, and you get a fixed price for the adjustment or the refit.
Got a list that needs working through?
Send it on WhatsApp with a photo or two and you get a price back, before anything is booked.
Send the list