Every retiling decision in Port Elizabeth comes down to this question within about ten minutes of starting. Tiling over the old floor is faster and cheaper on paper. Stripping it first is more work and more mess. Which one is right depends almost entirely on four things that have nothing to do with the tiles.
What tiling over tiles actually involves
You are not gluing new tiles to the old surface with the same adhesive. A proper tile-over job uses a suitable primer or bonding agent, a flexible adhesive designed for the situation, and enough depth to allow for any height differences in the existing floor.
It works when the old tiles are firmly bonded, flat, and sound. It fails when any of those three is not true, and the failure is usually a hollow, drummy patch where the new tile lifts a year later.
The old surface becomes the substrate. Whatever was wrong with it stays wrong, just buried.
The height problem, which is the real cost
Two layers of floor tile add somewhere in the region of 15mm to 20mm in total once adhesive is included. That sounds like nothing until you check what it meets.
Doors. An internal door with a 20mm gap under it is fine. One with 8mm now drags on the new floor, and the fix is to remove the door, plane the bottom and refit, which is a job on its own and one that shows up on our door repair pricing.
Skirtings. If the new floor comes above the bottom of the skirting, you either add a shoe moulding or remove and refit the skirtings at the new height. Both are time and both are visible.
The shower. In a bathroom, a raised floor can leave the shower base lower than the tiles around it, which is a drainage problem rather than a cosmetic one.
The step. A floor that meets an outside stoep now has a small step where it used to be flush.
None of these are reasons not to do it. They are the costs that people forget when they compare a quick tile-over quote against a strip and retile.
What stripping adds
Stripping is labour, disposal and making good.
The old tiles come up with a chisel or a breaker, the adhesive bed comes off next, and then the substrate has to be sound enough to tile on. On a concrete floor that usually means a screed or a self-levelling compound over the worst areas. On a suspended timber floor it means checking that the boards are fixed down properly, because a floor that flexes will crack tiles no matter what adhesive is used.
Then there is the skip. Tile rubble is heavy, and a bathroom plus a kitchen is a substantial amount to remove.
This is why stripping is often quoted as a separate line. It is not padding. It is a different day of work.
How to tell what you have
Four checks before you decide.
Tap across the floor with a coin or the handle of a screwdriver. A hollow, rattling sound means the tile has separated from the bed. A dull thud means it is solid. If a patch sounds hollow, tiling over it is a bet.
Look at the grout lines. Cracks running in a straight line usually follow a joint in the substrate or a movement issue. That floor is telling you something.
Check the door gaps and the skirting heights now, before the quote, not after the tiles are on.
Look for previous repairs. A patch of different tiles in a corner usually means something happened there, and it is worth knowing what.
One more check that costs nothing: put a straight edge or a level across the floor in two directions. If a 1.2 metre level rocks, the floor is not flat, and the size of the gap tells you whether adhesive can take it up or whether a screed is needed first.
The adhesive question, and where cheap goes wrong
A tile-over job is only as good as what holds it down. Standard tile adhesive is not designed to bond to a glazed surface, so the existing tiles need a bonding agent or a primer, and the adhesive itself needs to be flexible enough to cope with the movement that is already in the old floor.
The grade of adhesive also has to match the tile. Large format porcelain needs a different adhesive and a different trowel from a small ceramic, because coverage under a big tile is harder to achieve and a void under the middle is a crack waiting to happen.
This is where a cheap quote and an expensive quote usually differ, and it is invisible once the job is done. The materials are not the expensive part. The labour and the risk are.
The walls are a different conversation
Tiling over tiles on a wall is far more common than on a floor, and the stakes are different.
Behind a kitchen counter, the height question barely matters. There is nothing to clear, nothing to step over, and the splashback can sit proud of the wall without consequence. The main job is making sure the old surface is sound and the adhesive grips.
In a bathroom shower, tile-over is a bad idea if there is any doubt about the waterproofing behind the existing tiles. The membrane is the thing that keeps water out of the wall, and covering it does not restore it. If there has been any damp in the room next door, the honest answer is strip, make good, waterproof, then tile.
When tiling over is the sensible choice
- The existing floor is sound, flat and firmly bonded.
- The height gain will not clash with doors, skirting or the shower.
- The room is small, so the adhesive and primer cost is low.
- You are working to a budget and the substrate is genuinely good.
- It is a floor rather than a wall in a wet area, where waterproofing has to be continuous.
On a wall, tiling over tiles is common in kitchens behind a splashback, where the height question barely matters. On a floor, it is a judgement call that a site visit settles.
When stripping is the only honest answer
- Any hollow or drummy areas, because the new tile will fail over them.
- A floor that is out of level by more than the adhesive can correct.
- Damp coming through the substrate. Sealing it under new tiles traps the problem.
- A bathroom where the waterproofing has reached the end of its life. You cannot fix a membrane through a floor.
- Anywhere the height gain breaks a door, a skirting line or a shower.
If a tiler quotes tile-over without checking for hollow tiles, that is the moment to ask how they know the floor is sound.
The price conversation
We do not publish a per square metre tiling rate, because a metre rate quoted before anyone has seen the room is a guess with confidence behind it. What we do instead is measure, check the substrate, agree the tile and the layout, and give a fixed price for the job with materials listed separately.
For context on national rates and why they vary so much between sources, our tiling cost guide sets out the published ranges per square metre and what each one includes.
There is also the disposal line, which is easy to overlook. Stripping generates rubble that has to leave the property, and a bathroom or kitchen floor is a substantial weight of it. A quote that includes stripping but not removal is a quote with a hole in it. Ask where the rubble goes.
What you will not get from us is a strip-and-retile price without a look at the floor, or a tile-over recommendation without the hollow test. Both are how the job goes wrong six months later.
The hollow test settles most arguments in a minute. It is the floor telling you whether tile-over is a saving or a bet.
What to do next
Take a photo of the floor, a photo of the door gap and a rough measurement. WhatsApp 067 397 3341 with those three things and you will get a first estimate that is worth something, and a fixed price after a visit.
If the floor turns out to be sound, tiling over saves you a day of mess. If it is not, you will hear it before the work starts rather than after.
Got a list that needs working through?
Send it on WhatsApp with a photo or two and you get a price back, before anything is booked.
Send the list